Pin it
Lobster Newburg is the kind of creamy seafood comfort that feels both fancy and super cozy. When I want to go all-out for dinner without making things too tricky, this is my pick. That rich, buttery sauce with a hint of sherry turns lobster into something everyone asks for again and again around here.
The first time I cooked this, my husband thought I called in a fancy order from a top-notch spot. Now he asks for it every birthday—like clockwork.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Toast points, puff pastry shells, or rice: These are your sturdy bases to soak up every drop of sauce
- Fresh parsley: Toss a handful on top right before serving—it perks everything up
- Cayenne pepper: Totally optional, but a tiny bit gives a gentle warmth that's great with seafood
- Salt and pepper: Add to taste so the flavors pop
- Ground nutmeg: Just a pinch, giving the sauce that little cozy boost
- Egg yolks: Stir these in for added richness and thickening power
- Dry sherry: That's where the famous sweet deep flavor comes in
- Heavy cream: Pour in to make every bite extra smooth
- All-purpose flour: Needed for thickening everything just right
- Butter: This is where the base gets its velvety kick
- Lobster meat: The undeniable star—fresh or good frozen is just fine
Easy-To-Follow Steps
- Spoon It Up and Garnish:
- Ladle the hot lobster mix onto your choice of toast, pastry, or rice. Top it with loads of parsley. Dive in while it's warm for the best bite.
- Add the Lobster Carefully:
- Put the lobster pieces in and gently turn them to coat. Give it a couple minutes so the lobster gets warm but stays soft and juicy.
- Mix in Spices and Sherry:
- Next up, pour in the sherry and shake in the nutmeg, salt, pepper, plus cayenne if you like a mild heat. Mix so the flavor goes through everything.
- Blend In the Yolks:
- With the heat low, stir those tempered yolks right into your sauce. Let it go for a minute or two to get sticky-smooth but don't let it bubble so you keep that velvety finish.
- Temper Those Yolks:
- Beat your egg yolks gently in a bowl, then whisk in a little of the hot sauce bit by bit—so they warm up without turning scrambly.
- Get the Sauce Thick:
- Now slowly pour in your cream as you whisk nonstop. Keep it just warm enough so it doesn't burn, and let it thicken up for a few minutes. You're looking for it to stick to your spoon.
- Cook the Roux:
- Sprinkle the flour into your melted butter and whisk it smooth. Let it cook so it doesn't taste raw about two minutes—it's your creamy base.
- Start with Butter:
- In a big sturdy pan on medium, add the butter. Let it melt until it foams but don't let it get brown—you want that sweet butter flavor to come through.
Pin it
Lobster always takes me back to seaside summers with my folks. I'm all about nutmeg in this—the little lift it gives the sauce is magic.
Keep It Fresh
Pop any leftovers in a sealed container in the fridge for two days tops. Warm it super slowly in a pot, stirring so your sauce stays together. If it thickens up too much, splash in some extra cream right before heating.
Switch Things Up
Can't get lobster? Cooked shrimp, scallops, or a seafood blend give a whole new vibe. Half and half works instead of cream if you want it lighter—it just won't be as rich. If you're out of sherry, a dry white wine does the job, though it'll taste a bit brighter, less sweet.
Serving Ideas
This dish feels extra nice heaped on crunchy toast, in those cute little pastry shells, or over plain rice. For a real treat, add some roasted potatoes, asparagus, and a crisp salad on the side. Squeeze some lemon over everything if you're into a bright finish.
How It All Began
Lobster Newburg popped up in New York City way back in the late 1800s at big dinner parties. The idea was to smother lobster in a creamy, sherry-spiked sauce using French tricks but with extra-rich American flavors.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How do I make sure the sauce stays smooth?
Splash a bit of the hot cream into your egg yolks and mix gently, then add this to the sauce and keep it from bubbling so it doesn't split.
- → What’s the easiest way to prep lobster meat?
Go for already cooked lobster (frozen or fresh). If frozen, let it thaw and dab the pieces dry so they turn out tender.
- → Can I cook the sauce in advance?
Yup, just stop before putting in the lobster. Warm the sauce carefully (don’t rush it) then add lobster right before you sit down to eat.
- → What if I want a lighter sauce?
Half-and-half works when you want something less heavy, and it's still nice and creamy.
- → How should I serve this meal?
Ladle it over pastry, toast, or fluffy rice so all that sauce doesn’t go to waste.
- → Want to give it more kick?
A dash of cayenne brings gentle heat, and chopped parsley over the top wakes up the colors and flavor.