Pin it
This cozy and rich New Mexico green chile chicken dish has stretchy cheese and bold Southwest flair. When friends stop by and there's a crispness in the air, I throw this together. Tangy fire-roasted chiles, tender chicken, and soft tortillas make it disappear fast every time.
This whole thing started after cruising through New Mexico. When I got home I just wanted food that took me back to those off-the-map café stops. Whenever I make it, we end up swapping road trip memories at the table.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Fresh cilantro: Sprinkle on at the end for a burst of flavor Use freshly chopped for the best taste
- Sour cream: Optional dollop for extra creaminess Full fat will make it extra rich
- Hatch green chile sauce or canned green enchilada sauce: Delivers that classic hit of New Mexico flavor Grab Hatch brand or go for roasted chiles if you score them
- Ground cumin: Deep, earthy Southwest vibes Pop for a fresh jar for the boldest taste
- Garlic: Mincing fresh gives the most fragrant kick
- Cooked chicken: Shred up roasted or store rotisserie Both work great Thighs keep it juicy
- Monterey Jack cheese: Shred your own to melt it perfectly Smooth and mild cheese
- Corn tortillas: Warm up gently so they bend and roll without trouble The classic layer for this meal
- Onion: Chopped small for moisture and sweet taste Yellow or white make it pop
- Cheddar cheese: Shred from a block so it melts nice and snag that sharp cheesy zing
- Salt: Lodges flavor into every bite Try sea salt or kosher if you like
- Black pepper: Adds a little warmth and rounds out the taste Cracked fresh is best
Simple How-To Steps
- Toss On Some Toppings:
- Once it’s bubbly and out of the oven, scatter cilantro over the top and let folks add their own sour cream for a fresh, creamy finish
- Bake Till Golden:
- Uncover and let it cook for about 25–30 minutes until the cheese goes melty and gold on top That smell will pull everyone into your kitchen
- Add Sauce and Layer:
- Pour a scoop of green chile sauce into the bottom so it won’t stick Line up all your rolled tortillas Pour the rest of the sauce over and sprinkle the last of the cheese everywhere for a yummy cheesy crust
- Fill and Roll 'Em Up:
- Lay out a tortilla, add chicken mixture and both cheeses, and snugly roll it Put each seam-side down in the dish Keep going until you’re out of filling
- Soften Those Tortillas:
- Either heat tortillas in a dry pan until bendy or zap them wrapped in a damp paper towel for half a minute Soft tortillas won’t split when you stuff them
- Make the Good Stuff:
- Cook diced onions and minced garlic in a skillet with a splash of oil over medium heat till they smell amazing and look see-through Toss in chicken, cumin, salt, and black pepper and heat until hot The chicken soaks up all that good taste
- Prep Your Pan:
- Fire up the oven to 190°C and grease your dish with a bit of oil or butter You don’t want anything sticking at the end
Pin it
Out of everything here, Hatch green chile sauce is top of my list. There’s this gentle smokiness in every spoonful that zips me right back to that unforgettable Santa Fe café. I dish it out whenever cold weather creeps in—passing around platters always sparks laughs and old stories at dinner.
Leftover Tips
Keep extras tightly wrapped up in the fridge and use within three days. The flavors mingle more as it sits, so leftovers really shine. Want to freeze it? Section out pieces for grab-and-go lunches or busy nights. Thaw in your fridge then reheat however you like, oven or microwave both work.
Swaps and Shortcuts
No corn tortillas? Flour ones are fine, just expect softer bites. Grab a rotisserie chicken to save time. Can’t find Hatch chiles? Swap in any green enchilada sauce, but a can or jar of fire roasted chiles will bring more depth if you find them.
Ways to Serve
This cheesy chicken goodness needs nothing extra, but it’s awesome with a bright orange and avocado salad or a crunchy cabbage slaw on the side. At parties, cut it in squares like enchiladas for easy sharing. For full Southwest vibes, spoon on guac and scoop up with beans.
Pin it
New Mexico and Southwest Roots
This meal gets its soul from New Mexico where fire-roasted Hatch chiles play a starring role in almost every dish. Generations have turned simple staples into real-deal comfort food. Warm, homey, and full of history, every forkful brings a dose of sunshine—even if it’s snowing outside.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What kind of green chile sauce should I use?
To keep things classic, use Hatch green chile sauce if you can. If you can't find it fresh, a good canned green enchilada sauce totally works too.
- → Could I swap corn tortillas for flour ones?
Corn tortillas give you that classic taste and feel, but flour ones are cool if you want something a bit softer and lighter.
- → Is it okay to make this ahead?
Definitely! Put it all together the day before, stash it covered in the fridge, then bake when you’re ready. It’ll taste just as good.
- → How hot is this dish?
The heat kicks in depending on the sauce. Stick to mild or medium if you’re not into spicy, or toss in more chile for a bigger punch.
- → What should I eat on the side?
Try it with Spanish rice, a green salad, or refried beans. Don’t forget a sprinkle of cilantro and a spoonful of sour cream on top!
- → Can I freeze what’s left?
For sure. Let it cool, slice it up, wrap each piece well, and stick it in the freezer. Warm it up in your oven so it stays nice and tasty.