Pin it
Butter chicken from India is pure feel-good comfort that's big on flavor and always fun to share any night. The creamy tomato sauce gets soaked up by the soft chicken and every mouthful pops with bright spices. The first time I cooked this for guests, the buttery smell had everyone crowding the kitchen before it was even time to eat
I dig how the creamy sauce just hugs the rice or naan and makes it super filling. The smell honestly turns my house into a cozy hangout spot
Irresistible Ingredients
- Fresh cilantro: Makes everything pop with green freshness pick a lively bunch with bright leaves
- Heavy cream: Pours in at the finish for that signature smoothness use the good stuff if you can
- Tomato sauce: Brings that punchy body and tang look for a pure simple sauce
- Grated ginger: A knuckle-sized piece peeled and grated wakes up the dish with a little warmth
- Garlic: Chopped garlic is a must for awesome flavor grab fresh and let it do its thing
- Large onion: Chopped for layers of sweetness and flavor go for a shiny unblemished one
- Butter: Real unsalted butter delivers all that rich base flavor
- Black pepper: Adds some mellow heat at the end grind it fresh right before
- Salt: Makes everything taste better fine kosher or sea salt does wonders
- Cayenne pepper: Where the fire comes from so go easy or wild as you like
- Ground coriander: Gives a citrusy punch fresher is always better
- Ground cumin: Lays down that smoky vibe so make sure yours still smells bold
- Ground turmeric: Sets the color and keeps things earthy use just plain turmeric powder no mixes
- Garam masala: The genius blend for warm deep notes find a good mix or grind your own if you can
- Lemon juice: Lifts it all up use a juicy lemon for the brightest zing
- Plain yogurt: Gives the chicken that often overlooked tang and makes it soft go for full fat
- Boneless skinless chicken thighs: They stay moist and grab all the flavors while simmering
Simple Steps
- Garnish and Plate:
- Scoop your buttery chicken into your dish give it a handful of fresh cilantro for color and brightness and dig in with rice or naan while it’s steaming hot
- Stir Chicken with Sauce:
- Take the cooked chicken from the oven chop it into chunks then fold it into that rich sauce let it sizzle together for a bit so all the flavors soak in
- Add Creamy Touch:
- With the heat turned down splash in your cream keep stirring till the sauce goes silky and orange let it bubble gently for a few more minutes until thick
- Pour in Tomato:
- Stir in the tomato sauce let it gently bubble for five minutes so everything blends smoothly and that tomato taste turns mellow
- Ginger Garlic Blooms:
- Toss in your minced garlic then grated ginger right on top of the soft onions let that magic perfume fill your kitchen for a couple minutes but don’t let it burn
- Sweat the Onions:
- Drop butter in a pan over medium swirl until melted, then add onion and cook slow for sweet golden results about eight minutes
- Chicken Gets Baked:
- Crank your oven to 400 F spread the marinated chicken on a lined tray roast twenty five to thirty minutes and let the tops start to caramelize
- Flavor Soak:
- Mix up yogurt lemon juice all your spices and salt and pepper in a big bowl throw in the chicken toss to coat everywhere and marinate for at least half an hour for max taste
Pin it
Honestly, my favorite part is the garam masala since every brand or shop has its own secret twist and the result is always a bit new. Cooking this with my brother for the first time was an epic mess but so much fun it’s still one of our best kitchen memories ever
Storage Wisdom
Stick your butter chicken in the fridge for up to four days and it somehow just gets better. Cool it down all the way first then pop it in a tight-sealing dish. Freezes like a charm too so make an extra round and stash in single portions for future lazy nights
Swap Outs
Want it dairy free? Swap coconut cream for the regular cream and it’ll taste a bit tropical. Only have chicken breast? It works but watch close so it doesn’t dry up. No plain yogurt? Greek yogurt will do but the texture will be a little thicker
Serving Ideas
Pile this chicken high on fluffy basmati rice or scoop with soft naan bread. On busy days I’ll add a side of cool cucumber salad or a dab of tangy mango chutney for a quick refresh. A shot of lime juice or extra cilantro right before eating gives a bright finish
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What gives the sauce its smooth, rich taste?
Butter and heavy cream are what make the sauce thick and velvety, mixing perfectly with the tomato base. If you want to skip dairy, swap in coconut cream for a similar feel.
- → Are other chicken cuts okay to use?
You bet. Try bone-in thighs or breast if you prefer. Just check doneness since times can shift based on the chicken's size and type.
- → Can I make it milder or spicier?
Totally. Just play around with your garam masala and cayenne until the heat matches what you like best.
- → What are good sides for this meal?
It's awesome with warm naan, fluffy basmati rice, or even a pile of veggies like bell pepper or peas if you want something lighter on the side.
- → Can leftovers last in the fridge or freezer?
Absolutely, leftovers keep well in your fridge a few days. It also freezes nicely—just rewarm it gently when you're ready to dig in.