Buffalo Cheese Melt

This zesty buffalo chicken grilled cheese turns basic sandwich bread into a knockout meal blending the zingy heat of buffalo sauce with melty cheeses and juicy chicken. It's my go-to sandwich when I want comfort food that packs a punch.

I threw this together during a big football game once, and now we can't watch Sunday sports without it. My little ones used to ask for "that hot cheese sandwich," but these days they straight up tell their buddies they'll be having buffalo chicken grilled cheese when they come over.

What You'll Need

• 8 slices sandwich bread: this is your base, so grab something sturdy that won't fall apart when it hits the pan
• 2 cups cooked chicken breasts, shredded: grabbing a rotisserie chicken saves tons of time, but any leftover chicken does the trick
• 2 teaspoons minced garlic: brings extra flavor to the buffalo mix, try to use fresh for the best taste
• 1/4 teaspoon cayenne pepper: gives it that extra kick, but feel free to skip it if you're feeding folks who can't handle heat
• 1 teaspoon ground black pepper: adds a nice warmth that works really well with the buffalo flavors
• 1/2 teaspoon paprika: throws in some smokiness and makes the cheese mix look amazing
• 1/2 cup hot sauce: Frank's is the classic choice for real buffalo taste, but whatever hot sauce you love will work
• 1/2 cup ranch dressing: cools down the spice and adds creaminess, homemade tastes way better than bottles
• 4 ounces cream cheese, softened: makes everything creamy and keeps your bread from getting mushy
• 4 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened: gives you that golden crunchy outside, make sure it's soft enough to spread easily
• 4–8 slices muenster cheese: melts like a dream and has a mild taste that works great with the spicy chicken
• 4 tablespoons crumbled blue cheese: brings that true buffalo wing flavor, so get the good stuff for the best tangy bite

How To Make It

Mix up the cheese blend:

Take a small bowl and mix your room temperature cream cheese with the blue cheese crumbles, paprika, black pepper, and cayenne. Stir everything until it's smooth. This tasty layer stops your bread from getting soggy and packs in lots of flavor. Make sure your cream cheese isn't cold or it won't mix well.

Create your buffalo chicken:

In another bowl, toss your shredded chicken with the hot sauce, ranch, and minced garlic. Stir until every bit of chicken is coated. The ranch helps balance out the heat while the garlic makes it more flavorful. Try to shred your chicken really well so you get all the good stuff in each bite.

Build your sandwiches:

Butter one side of each bread slice. Flip them over and spread the cheese mixture on four of the slices. Add about 1/2 cup of the chicken mix on top of the cheese spread. Put one or two slices of muenster on the other bread slices and close up your sandwiches. Remember, butter goes on the outside.

Cook them just right:

Spray a big skillet with cooking spray. Put the sandwiches in and cook them on low heat for 5 minutes until they're golden and crunchy. Flip them over and cook another 5 minutes on the other side. Going slow and low makes sure all the cheese gets melty while your bread gets perfectly crispy without burning.

Dig in right away:

Take the sandwiches off the heat and let them sit for a minute before you cut them. This helps the melted cheese firm up a bit so it doesn't all squish out. Serve with extra buffalo sauce, ranch, or blue cheese dressing for dipping if you want even more flavor.

Pin it

Blue cheese totally changed how I feel about buffalo chicken. I always thought it was too strong, but when it's mixed with cream cheese, it creates this amazing tangy flavor that works perfectly with the spicy buffalo sauce. Now I always keep some blue cheese crumbles in my fridge just for making this sandwich.

Prep Ahead Tips

You can totally get a jump on this sandwich. Make the buffalo chicken mix and the cheese spread up to three days early and keep them in separate containers in the fridge. When you're hungry, just throw your sandwiches together and grill them up for fresh hot sandwiches in no time. The chicken mixture actually tastes even better after sitting for a day as all the flavors blend together.

What To Serve With It

These sandwiches go great with cooling sides that balance out their heat. I really like a simple green salad with cucumber and ranch on the side. If you want something more filling, try some oven-baked fries or sweet potato wedges next to your spicy sandwich. Having it for lunch? A cup of tomato soup makes for that classic grilled cheese combo that cuts through the richness.

Keeping Leftovers

You can wrap cooked sandwiches in foil and keep them in the fridge for a couple days. When you want to eat them, warm them up in a 350°F oven for about 10–15 minutes to get them crispy again. The oven works way better than the microwave, which can make your bread all soggy. For the best results though, store your uncooked sandwiches and grill them right before eating.

Switch It Up

Try using different breads like sourdough or thick Texas toast for new flavors. Watching your carbs? Wrap everything in lettuce instead of bread. The chicken mix also tastes great as a dip with celery and carrot sticks, or spooned over a baked potato. Want to make it extra indulgent? Add some crispy bacon strips before you grill the sandwich.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use a different kind of cheese for this sandwich?

Sure thing! Feel free to replace muenster or blue cheese with options like Monterey Jack, mozzarella, Colby Jack, or sharp white cheddar. Each will bring its own unique texture and taste.

→ What’s the best way to store and reheat leftovers?

Wrap the sandwiches in foil and keep them in the fridge for up to two days. Reheat in an oven preheated to 175°C (350°F) for 10-15 minutes to keep the bread crispy. Avoid microwaving, as it might make them soggy.

→ Can I make the buffalo chicken mix in advance?

Definitely! Prep the chicken mixture and keep it chilled in a sealed container for up to two days. Whip up the cream cheese mix ahead too, so sandwich assembly is a breeze!

→ How can I customize this sandwich for more flavor?

Toss in fresh avocado slices, diced tomatoes, or some finely chopped celery for a bit of crunch and a fresh twist. These extras balance out the spicy kick nicely.

→ What type of bread works best for these sandwiches?

Sourdough, brioche, or thick Texas toast all work great here. Pick a heartier bread that crisps up well and can hold the filling without falling apart.

→ How can I tone down the heat in this sandwich?

Cut back on the hot sauce, and skip any cayenne powder. For a milder option, blend some butter into the hot sauce or use a less-spicy brand of hot sauce entirely.