Pin it
This alcohol-free strawberry piña colada tastes like summer in a cup—fruity, creamy, and totally bright. When you want to celebrate with something fun but don’t want booze, you can throw this together fast with stuff you probably already have. I whip this up on lazy afternoons or at backyard parties. Every time, it’s barely any work and gives total vacation vibes.
This drink stole the show at my very first pool party. The adults ended up grabbing seconds when they saw all the kiddos loving theirs. Now it’s my not-so-secret trick for easy entertaining.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Pineapple wedges: Slice up some small pineapple triangles for a cozy, fancy finish on your glass
- Fresh strawberries: Pick the brightest berries with their leafy tops if you’re all about that garnish
- Ice: Go for clean-tasting cubes so your mix stays cool and has no weird flavors
- Honey or agave syrup: Add if you like extra sweetness, but taste your berries first. Really ripe ones might be sweet enough!
- Pineapple juice: Zippy flavor that balances the thick coconut—fresh is best, but solid bottled stuff works, too
- Coconut milk or cream: This ingredient is what makes it thick and silky; use the full-fat can for a rich feel and skip watery ones
- Fresh or frozen strawberries: Ripe and sweet is what you want, fully red, and fragrant for loads of flavor
Simple Step-by-Step
- Drink it Right Away:
- Chug it while it’s icy-cold and slushy—don’t let it hang around or the ice will melt and mess up the texture.
- Serve Like a Pro:
- Pour your mix into chilly glasses. Stick a whole berry and pineapple chunk on each rim for a festive touch.
- Make it the Perfect Drink:
- If yours is too thick, just pause, pour a bit more coconut milk or pineapple juice in, and run the blender again. Keep it dreamy and smooth, not thin or runny.
- Time to Blend:
- Toss your strawberries, coconut cream or milk, pineapple juice, honey (or agave), and ice in the blender. Start slow, then crank it up until it’s super smooth—no icy chunks allowed.
- Get the Fruit Prepped:
- Snip off the green bits and any white patches on your strawberries. Check your coconut milk for blobs and shake it up if you need to. Chill your pineapple juice for max refreshment.
Pin it
Honestly, I can’t get enough of seeing kids light up when you hand them one of these in a fun glass. My niece once made everyone score their drinks and would always add more pineapple because she couldn’t get enough of the combo.
Storing Leftovers
If you’ve got extra, pour it into popsicle molds for easy frozen snacks the next day. Or stash in the fridge for a quick treat within 24 hours—just give it a big stir before serving. It’s really best fresh from the blender though.
Switching Up Ingredients
Out of coconut milk? Use light canned coconut milk if you want something a bit lighter, or almond milk for a totally different flavor. No fresh strawberries? Frozen works, just use less ice. Want a deeper sweetness? Try maple syrup instead of honey or agave.
Fun Ways to Serve
Pour it into tall glasses with a handful of crushed ice for maximum island feels. Try a paper umbrella or sprinkle some shaved coconut across the top for parties. Sometimes I whiz in a couple of fresh mint leaves for extra zap and use them as garnish, too.
Pin it
Backstory and Traditions
The classic piña colada started in Puerto Rico, normally mixing rum, coconut, and pineapple. This non-boozy spin drops the rum and tosses in strawberries for a sweet tweak. Super popular at summer hangouts and anytime you’re dreaming of the beach.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Will frozen strawberries be okay?
Frozen strawberries work great, and they even help make the drink thicker and colder. They’re super useful if you can’t get fresh berries.
- → Is there another option for coconut milk?
Swap in coconut cream for a richer sip, or pick your favorite plant milk if you want it lighter.
- → What should I do to sweeten it up?
Squeeze in some honey or a bit of agave if you like it sweeter, or skip sugar for a more natural taste. Blend first, then taste and change it up if you want.
- → How do I make it thick and creamy?
Grab coconut cream for more richness. Or, splash in extra coconut milk or toss in more ice cubes for a chunkier texture.
- → What's the nicest way to serve it?
Fill up cold glasses with your blend, drop in some fresh pineapple or strawberries on top for color and bite.