Pin it
Nothing beats how juicy peaches mingle with tart white cheddar and smooth ricotta inside crunchy, golden bread slices. Add in honey’s sweetness and that crisp buttery bite—you get my ultimate summer go-to that vanishes as soon as I set it on the table.
The first time I put this together was on a bright sunny day, right after peaches hit the stands. My husband totally doubted it—now he swears it’s the best grilled cheese he’s ever had.
Vibrant Ingredients
- White cheddar cheese: For seriously bold and tangy melt, grab extra-sharp if possible
- Honey: Drizzle on top to bring gentle sweetness and shine raw honey packs tons of flavor
- Sourdough, challah, thick white, or multigrain bread: All toast up perfectly and stay sturdy
- Balsamic glaze (optional): Drizzle a little if you’re after sweet and tangy flavors pick a thick, tasty one
- Peaches (peeled and sliced): Stick with firmer, just-ripe fruit for the best bite and flavor
- Unsalted butter: Butter’s the trick for crisp golden outsides and keeps things from sticking
- Ricotta cheese: Spreads easy and adds creamy balance full-fat gives extra richness
- Fresh basil (optional): For a burst of herby freshness grab a few fragrant leaves
- Bacon (optional): If you want crunch and a salty kick, cook until really crispy first
Irresistible Step-by-Step
- Serve It Up:
- Slice that sandwich straight from the pan so the cheese is melty and stretchy, and eat while still warm for the best bite
- Toss On Extras:
- Like bacon, basil, or glaze? Open the top after grilling and tuck them in, then press the bread back down
- Fire Up the Grill:
- Preheat your heavy skillet or press right over medium-low stack sandwiches in, squish gently, and grill till all golden and gooey drop the heat if edges brown too fast
- Butter the Bread:
- Cover the outside of every slice with butter not missing any spots—it makes things super crunchy
- Build the Layers:
- Stack peach slices on half your ricotta-spread bread add honey next, then top with cheddar on the other half so the melt’s even
- Spread the Ricotta:
- Coat one side of each bread slice with ricotta using a spoon to get every corner so the toppings stick
- Prep the Peaches:
- Peel your peaches, then slice into skinny pieces so they soften up and won’t slip out
Pin it
White cheddar always brings me back to rainy afternoons as a kid when my grandma’s kitchen smelled like warm toast. Adding peaches and honey turns that cozy mood into a sunny treat and it’s a favorite for lazy Sundays with my kids now.
Simple Storage Tricks
Let the sandwiches cool down before wrapping snug in foil then tuck into the fridge. To bring back the crunch, warm them in a toaster oven or pan—not the microwave or they’ll get soggy.
Swap Options
No peaches? Nectarines or thin pear slices work nicely. You can swap ricotta for goat cheese, and for a different cheesy note, try Swiss or Gruyere instead of cheddar.
How to Serve
Slice on the diagonal for fun, then plate with fresh berries or a green salad. Sip on some iced tea to round out a chill summer meal.
Background Story
This sandwich mixes old-school American grilled cheese with a classic cheese-and-fruit combo you’ll see around the Mediterranean. Using local juicy peaches and that dash of honey gives it a summery, homey twist that feels a little special.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How do I stop the bread from turning soggy?
Lightly butter both sides and cook on low-medium heat. This lets the inside stay melty while the outside crisps instead of soaking up moisture.
- → Could I swap the bread for something else?
Of course. Thick bread like challah or multigrain holds up and boosts the flavor.
- → What goes great on the side?
Try a crunchy green salad, roasted veggies, or a light broth. They balance out the sweet cheesy sandwich.
- → How thin should the peach slices be?
Slice the peaches super thin so every bite cooks evenly and goes smooth with the cheese and bread.
- → Is the bacon a must-have?
Skip it if you want. Crispy bacon is fun for extra crunch, but it's totally your call.
- → What if I don't want honey? Can I swap it?
Sure, leave it out if you like, or swap in maple syrup for a little different sweetness.