Pin it
These nutty sandwich treats hit the sweet spot with just the right mix of rich peanut flavor and gentle sweetness that'll take you back to your childhood days. When you bite into the crispy cookies with their smooth peanut butter middle, you get a snack that feels like old times but tastes amazingly good.
I whipped these cookies up one rainy day when my children were getting antsy from being stuck inside. The moment that familiar peanut butter smell filled our home, everything felt better. Now they ask for these sandwich treats whenever we're celebrating something.
What You'll Need
- All purpose flour: makes the cookies nice and soft in just the right way
- Baking soda: helps them rise a bit without getting too fluffy
- Salt: brings out all the tastes and cuts through the sweetness
- Unsalted butter: adds a nice richness and helps make the edges crunchy
- Creamy peanut butter: gives the main flavor so grab a good brand
- Granulated sugar: helps create that perfect cookie feel
- Brown sugar: makes the cookies deeper in flavor and keeps them moist
- Large egg: holds everything together nicely
- Vanilla extract: makes the warm flavors pop even more
- Creamy peanut butter: gives you that yummy filling go for the smooth kind
- Powdered sugar: makes the filling sweet and solid
- Vanilla extract: gives it that extra smell and taste
- Unsalted butter: lets you spread the filling easily
Making Your Cookies
- Get Ready:
- Start by turning your oven to 350°F and putting parchment on two cookie sheets. The parchment stops sticking and makes cleaning up super easy. Get all your stuff out on the counter so it's ready to go.
- Handle Dry Stuff:
- In a bowl, stir the flour, baking soda, and salt together really well. Getting everything mixed evenly means your cookies will turn out just right. Break up any flour lumps for the smoothest dough.
- Make Your Mix:
- In a bigger bowl, mix the soft butter, peanut butter, white sugar, and brown sugar. Beat it until it looks lighter and gets fluffy, around 2 3 minutes. This puts air in the mix so your cookies aren't too dense.
- Add Wet Stuff:
- Drop in the egg and vanilla to your butter mix, and beat until it's all smooth. It should look kind of shiny when done. Scrape the bowl sides to get everything mixed in good.
- Put It All Together:
- Slowly add your dry stuff to the wet mix, stirring on low just until it comes together. Don't mix too much or your cookies will get tough. Stop as soon as the flour disappears.
- Form The Cookies:
- Scoop out dough bits about a tablespoon big and roll them into balls. Put them on your cookie sheets with about 2 inches between them so they can spread out. Push each one with a fork to make criss crosses and flatten them a bit.
- Cook Them:
- Bake your cookies for 10 12 minutes until the edges get golden but the middles stay soft. They might look a bit raw in the center but they'll harden up as they cool. Swap the pans halfway through for even baking.
- Let Them Cool:
- Let the cookies sit on the hot sheets for 5 minutes, then move them to a wire rack to cool all the way. This sitting time helps them firm up without breaking. Make sure they're totally cool before you add filling.
- Fix The Filling:
- While cooling happens, beat together peanut butter, powdered sugar, vanilla, and soft butter until it's smooth and fluffy. The filling should be thick enough to stay put but still easy to spread. If it's too thick, put in a tiny bit of milk.
- Put Them Together:
- When cookies are cool, spread lots of filling on the flat side of one cookie. Put another cookie on top, flat side down, and press gently to make a sandwich. The filling should reach the edges but not squish out.
Pin it
My favorite thing about making these cookies is watching my husband sneaking them from our cookie jar. We've had them monthly for years now, but he still thinks I don't see when the pile gets smaller overnight. It's turned into our funny little game that we never talk about.
Keeping Them Fresh
These peanut butter treats stay good in a sealed container at room temp for roughly a week. The filling actually keeps the cookies softer longer than regular peanut butter cookies would stay. If you want to keep them even longer, lay them flat in a freezer container with parchment between the layers. They freeze really well for up to three months. Just let them sit out for about an hour before you eat them.
Tasty Twists
The basic recipe is pretty awesome, but you can switch things up in lots of ways. Try using chunky peanut butter instead of smooth for some extra crunch in both the cookies and filling. If you love chocolate, mix tiny chocolate chips into the cookie dough or drizzle melted chocolate over the finished sandwiches. During holiday times, roll the edges of your filled cookies in fun sprinkles or crushed peanuts to make them look special.
Pin it
Ways to Enjoy
These peanut butter sandwich cookies go perfectly with a cold glass of milk or a hot cup of coffee for an afternoon break. For something really fancy, put a small scoop of vanilla ice cream between two cookies and freeze them solid. They also make great gifts when packed in pretty tins, especially for friends who love peanut butter. Put them on a plate with different cookies to show off all the cool textures and flavors.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long will these cookies last after baking?
Keep them sealed tight in a container at room temperature, and they’ll stay delicious for up to 7 days. Want to store longer? Freeze them for 3 months!
- → Can I swap smooth peanut butter for chunky?
Go for it! Crunchy peanut butter adds texture to your cookies. While the filling might not be as velvety, it’ll have an extra crunch that pairs well.
- → Why is the crosshatch pattern important on the cookies?
The fork-made pattern isn’t just for looks. It flattens the cookies so they bake evenly and adds a fun visual texture after baking.
- → What should I do if my dough feels sticky?
If the dough is tricky to handle, chill it in the fridge for 30 minutes. This will make it firmer and easier to work with, plus help the cookies keep their shape as they bake.
- → When do I know the cookies are done in the oven?
Once the edges start to turn golden, they’re ready! This usually takes around 10-12 minutes. The center might look soft, but leave them to cool, and they’ll set beautifully.
- → Can I prepare these ahead for a party?
Yes, definitely! You can bake the cookies a day or two in advance. If you want peak freshness, wait to add the filling until the day you’ll serve them!