Pin it
This Amish Hamburger Steak Bake is seriously the ultimate cozy meal. You get thick, juicy patties smothered in a creamy, mushroom-packed sauce all bubbly and golden from the oven. The minute you smell it, you’ll want to dig in right away. It always reminds me of chilly nights around our old dinner table—gone in a heartbeat every single time.
I’ll be honest, I never get over how often my kids come back for more. Even my pickiest eater loves it so now it’s part of our regular dinner routine.
Delicious Ingredients
- Worcestershire sauce: gives your meal that hit of tangy flavor Look for a real anchovy one if you want an old-school taste
- Mushrooms: bring that earthy flavor along with some chew Pick firm white or cremini ones then slice them up
- Small onion: gives yummy sweetness and extra texture Try for a heavy one—it’ll taste the best
- Milk: keeps everything nice and creamy Go with whole milk if you want it really rich
- Cream of mushroom soup: thickens the sauce Find a canned version that isn’t watery
- Black pepper: brings some mild heat Fresh cracked really livens things up
- Salt: lifts all the flavors Taste while you season so you don’t go overboard
- Onion powder: packs in more flavor Pick one with a strong, fresh smell
- Garlic powder: adds depth but not too much bite Choose a fresh-smelling one for the fullest taste
- Large egg: keeps the patties from falling apart Go for good quality so the mix holds together
- Breadcrumbs: stop everything from crumbling Use plain ones without seasoning, homemade or store bought
- Ground beef: makes a filling base with real meaty flavor Pick one with a bit of fat so it stays juicy
- Fresh parsley: gives the whole thing brightness Chop it up right before serving for the freshest look and taste
Easy-to-Follow Steps
- Sprinkle and Serve:
- Add chopped parsley at the end and get ready to scoop everything up with some noodles or mashed potatoes
- Uncover to Finish:
- Peel off the foil and bake ten minutes more so you get those bubbling edges and toasty bits on top
- Bake It Covered:
- Wrap the dish with foil before baking for thirty to thirty five minutes so the flavors really come together and patties cook through
- Add and Assemble:
- Layer the sauce all over the patties then scatter on sliced mushrooms and onions until you’ve got them covered
- Whisk the Sauce:
- In a new bowl, mix your soup, milk, and Worcestershire till you’ve got a creamy blend with no lumps
- Sear for Flavor:
- Heat your pan to medium and cook patties two or three minutes per side until you see that brown crust but still a little pink inside Move them right to your baking dish after
- Shape Those Patties:
- Get a big bowl and gently mix beef, breadcrumbs, egg, garlic, onion powder, salt, and pepper Shape four to six ovals but don’t mix too long or they’ll get tough
- Ready the Pan:
- Grease up a nine by thirteen inch baking dish and pop the oven to three fifty so it’s hot when you need it
Pin it
If you skip searing the patties you’ll miss that awesome crust. My grandma always swore the crispy outside made the dish and honestly, she was right. Every time I make it now, that’s what I’m looking forward to most.
How to Store Leftovers
If you’ve got leftovers, just cover the dish and pop it in the fridge for up to three days. Warm it slowly in the oven, or zap a piece in the microwave if you’re in a rush. Want to save some for later? Make sure it cools all the way, then wrap it tight and freeze for about two months.
Swap Options
Don’t have mushroom soup? Cream of chicken works and makes a lighter version. Watching carbs or need it gluten free? Almond flour does the job instead of breadcrumbs. Even ground turkey is great if you want to change up the protein.
What to Serve With It
This one goes so well with soft mashed potatoes or twirly egg noodles. Sometimes I add buttery corn or roasted green beans to round things out and give it that homey vibe.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I swap in cream of chicken soup for the mushroom kind?
For sure! Cream of chicken will taste a bit different but still give you that smooth texture and rich flavor you want.
- → How do I make sure the hamburger steaks stay moist?
Just give the patties a quick sear to hold in the juices, then let them bake with the sauce on top. They'll come out super juicy and soft.
- → Is almond flour okay to use in place of breadcrumbs?
Yep, almond flour works just fine if you're looking for a lower carb option. It helps hold everything together, too.
- → What goes well on the side?
Mashed potatoes and egg noodles are classics. Or go for steamed veggies or a leafy salad to round things out.
- → Can I get things ready before I need to bake it?
Absolutely. Make the patties and sauce ahead, pop the dish in the fridge, and bake just before it's time to eat. Makes dinner a snap!