Pin it
Flaky cream cheese pastry cradles a rich mushroom filling in these elegant hand pies that transform humble ingredients into something truly special. Each bite delivers the perfect contrast of textures—buttery, crisp exterior giving way to a savory, earthy filling that's been carefully caramelized to concentrate its flavor. I discovered this recipe decades ago when looking for make ahead appetizers for holiday entertaining, and it's since become my signature contribution to gatherings year round, earning devoted fans and recipe requests wherever they appear.
I first made these turnovers for a holiday cocktail party when I wanted something beyond the usual cheese plate or spinach dip. The moment I set them out, still warm from the oven, guests began asking about the recipe before they'd even finished their first bite. What began as an ambitious cooking project has become a cherished tradition, with friends and family checking to make sure "those mushroom things" will be making an appearance at gatherings. Even my mushroom skeptical nephew, who approaches anything fungus related with extreme caution, has been known to sneak extras when he thinks no one is looking.
Quality Components
- Mushrooms: White button varieties provide the perfect balance of flavor and texture mince them finely for the most elegant filling
- Shallots: Their delicate onion flavor complements mushrooms perfectly mince finely for even distribution throughout the filling
- Fresh thyme: The earthy, aromatic notes enhance the mushrooms' natural flavor strip leaves from stems before measuring
- Cream cheese: Creates exceptionally tender, flaky pastry use full fat, cold from the refrigerator for best results
- Butter: European style with higher fat content creates extraordinary flakiness keep ice cold until the moment you use it
- All purpose flour: Provides structure without toughness measure by spooning into cups and leveling for accuracy
- Sour cream: Adds tangy richness to the filling full fat creates the most luxurious texture
Pin it
Creation Method
Filling Development
Cook mushrooms slowly and patiently until all liquid evaporates and they begin to caramelize, concentrating their flavor dramatically. This crucial step transforms watery mushrooms into an intensely savory filling with deep, complex notes. The careful addition of thyme and black pepper enhances the earthy quality without overwhelming, while a touch of flour and sour cream creates the perfect consistency—thick enough to stay put when bitten into, yet still moist and luxurious.
Pastry Perfection
Combine ingredients with a light touch, working quickly to keep everything cold. This thoughtful technique prevents the butter and cream cheese from melting prematurely, which would compromise the pastry's flakiness. The brief resting period allows the flour to hydrate fully and the gluten to relax, resulting in dough that's easier to roll and produces more tender turnovers. This careful approach creates pastry that shatters delicately when bitten, then melts in your mouth.
Assembly Precision
Roll dough to consistent thickness and cut clean circles with a fluted cutter for professional looking results. This attention to detail ensures even baking and creates turnovers with the perfect ratio of pastry to filling. The thoughtful step of trimming edges after filling creates a neat, uniform appearance that elevates these appetizers from homemade to seemingly professional. This meticulous assembly might seem fussy but results in turnovers that are as beautiful as they are delicious.
Strategic Freezing
Freeze filled turnovers individually on baking sheets before packaging to prevent sticking and damage. This two stage freezing process preserves their shape and allows you to remove exactly the number you need for each occasion. The unbaked pastry and filling freeze perfectly, allowing you to bake them months later with results identical to freshly made versions. This make ahead capability transforms a time consuming recipe into a convenient entertaining solution.
Baking Brilliance
Brush with egg yolk just before baking to create a gorgeous golden finish that signals the flaky delights within. The slightly higher temperature for frozen turnovers compensates perfectly for their chilled state, allowing them to puff and brown beautifully without overcooking. This careful baking approach ensures consistent results whether you're baking them fresh or months after preparing them. The visual appeal of these perfectly golden half moons creates immediate appetite appeal.
Growing up, my grandmother would spend days preparing for holiday gatherings, insisting that homemade offerings expressed care in a way store bought never could. These turnovers honor that tradition while acknowledging modern realities—they require a time investment upfront but provide the convenience of having homemade appetizers ready whenever needed. There's something deeply satisfying about pulling a bag of these from the freezer when unexpected guests arrive, knowing that in twenty minutes I'll be serving something made with my own hands that never fails to impress and delight.
Serving Suggestions
These versatile turnovers adapt beautifully to various occasions and serving styles. Arrange on a simple white platter for elegant contrast at cocktail parties, perhaps with a small bowl of additional sour cream for dipping. For casual gatherings, serve alongside a cheese board where their savory profile complements various cheeses beautifully. During holiday open houses, keep batches going in the oven to ensure warm turnovers throughout the event. For dinner parties, serve three per person as a sophisticated first course alongside a small salad of bitter greens dressed with a light vinaigrette.
Creative Variations
My kitchen experiments have yielded several adaptations worth exploring. Create a version with wild mushroom varieties like shiitake or oyster for more complex flavor notes perfect for mycology enthusiasts. For Mediterranean inspiration, add a sprinkle of crumbled feta and a few pine nuts to the traditional filling. Those seeking additional richness might appreciate the addition of a splash of cream sherry to the mushroom mixture as it reduces, creating subtle depth and sweetness that complements the earthiness beautifully.
Pin it
Make Ahead Wisdom
Maximize these turnovers' convenience through strategic preparation approaches. Set aside a movie night or rainy afternoon for assembly, breaking the process into manageable steps—make the filling one day and the pastry the next if time is limited. Label freezer bags with both the date and baking instructions so anyone can prepare them successfully. For the most efficient use of ingredients, double the filling recipe and freeze half for future use, making the next batch of turnovers come together even more quickly.
After years of making these turnovers for countless gatherings, I've come to appreciate how they represent the perfect balance between effort and reward. What begins as a somewhat time consuming project yields dozens of elegant appetizers that never fail to impress and can be enjoyed for months afterward. There's something magical about the transformation of simple ingredients—mushrooms, butter, flour—into something so sophisticated through nothing more than careful technique and a bit of patience.
These mushroom turnovers represent what I love most about cooking—creating something greater than the sum of its parts through understanding of ingredients and techniques. They remind us that sometimes the most memorable dishes require an investment of time that pays dividends in satisfaction. Whether you're seeking reliable make ahead appetizers for entertaining or wanting to create a special homemade treat, these flaky, savory bites deliver both impressive results and the genuine pleasure that comes from sharing something made with care.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use a different filling instead of mushrooms?
- Absolutely! While the mushroom filling is classic, this cream cheese pastry works beautifully with many other fillings. Try cooked ground meat with herbs, spinach and feta, or even sweet fillings like cinnamon apple. Just ensure any filling you use isn't too wet (it should hold its shape when placed on the dough) and that all meats are fully cooked before assembling the turnovers.
- → How long can I keep these turnovers in the freezer?
- These turnovers freeze exceptionally well and can be stored in airtight, labeled freezer bags for up to 3 months without any loss of quality. For longer storage (up to 6 months), consider double-wrapping them or using a vacuum sealer to prevent freezer burn. Remember to bake them directly from frozen - do not thaw first.
- → The pastry seems sticky. What am I doing wrong?
- Cream cheese pastry can be a bit sticky to work with. Make sure your butter and cream cheese are very cold before starting. If the dough becomes too soft or sticky during rolling, simply return it to the refrigerator for 15-20 minutes to firm up. Liberal use of flour on your work surface and rolling pin will also help. Don't worry too much - this pastry is more forgiving than traditional pie crust.
- → Can I make these larger for a main dish?
- Yes! For a main dish, you can cut larger circles (4-5 inches) and increase the filling accordingly. These larger turnovers make a lovely light lunch or dinner paired with a salad. The baking time will need to be increased by about 5-7 minutes for larger pastries - just watch for that golden-brown color.
- → Can I use dried mushrooms instead of fresh?
- Yes, dried mushrooms can add wonderful concentrated flavor. Rehydrate them first in warm water for about 20-30 minutes, then drain thoroughly and chop. Mix them with fresh mushrooms for the best texture and flavor balance. Remember that rehydrated dried mushrooms can be quite potent, so you might want to reduce the amount slightly compared to fresh mushrooms.