Creamy Orange Cookie Base

This Jello Citrus Delight turns that nostalgic orange popsicle feeling into a smooth, dreamy dessert sitting in a rich cookie base. The bright orange taste mixed with silky cream cheese makes a cool treat that's just what you need when it's blazing hot and you're craving something chilled and satisfying.

I whipped this pie up for my kid's swim bash last summer, and it was gone in minutes—way before any other sweet treat. The zingy orange flavor brings back those fun memories of running after ice cream trucks, but it's got this fancy creaminess that grown-ups love just as much as children do.

Ingredients

• Shortbread cookies give you that buttery, crumbly foundation that works so well with the smooth filling on top
• Fresh orange and zest bring real citrus punch that you just can't get from anything in a can
• Orange Jello gives that eye-catching color and helps create that classic popsicle taste you remember
• Cream cheese adds that wonderful tang that cuts through the sweetness perfectly
• Cool Whip makes everything airy and gives you that cloud-like texture
• Sweetened condensed milk brings thickness and helps everything stay together nicely
• Vanilla extract adds depth and makes all the other flavors taste even better

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the Pan

Spray your deep pie dish so nothing sticks. This quick step saves you trouble when you're trying to get those pretty slices later.

Create the Cookie Crust

Crush those shortbread cookies until they look like damp sand. Mix them with melted butter until everything's wet. Push the mix firmly into your dish, covering bottom and sides evenly. Freezing it makes the butter harden, giving you a solid base that won't fall apart.

Develop the Orange Flavor Base

Blend those fresh oranges with zest, vanilla, and juice until it's totally smooth with no bits left. This gives you that amazing natural orange flavor throughout the whole dessert. Fresh stuff really matters here.

Form the Creamy Base

Mix cream cheese with Jello powder until it's completely smooth. Don't rush this part because you don't want any lumps. The Jello doesn't just add flavor, it helps everything stay together too.

Create the Light Texture

Carefully fold in the condensed milk and Cool Whip with a rubber spatula. Don't be too rough or you'll lose all the air that makes the Cool Whip so fluffy. This gives you that melt-in-your-mouth feel.

Combine the Flavor Elements

Mix the orange blend into your cream cheese mixture until everything's fully combined. You want that orange taste in every single bite. The fresh oranges add just enough tartness to balance out the sweetness.

Fill the Crust

Pour everything into your crust and smooth the top with a spatula. Leave a little room at the top for the final layer.

Chill to Set

Put it in the fridge for something softer or the freezer if you want it more like ice cream. You've got to wait here because it needs time to set up properly. The filling can't be rushed.

Create Luxurious Topping

Beat the leftover cream cheese with Cool Whip until it's super fluffy. This makes a soft, cloud-like topping that looks great against the orange part.

Garnish for Presentation

Add your whipped topping and put some fresh orange slices on top to make it pretty. This final touch shows what's inside and makes it look like you got it from a fancy bakery.

Pin it

The orange zest is really what makes this pie stand out. I keep a special grater just for citrus in recipes like this one. My grandma always told me that zest has all the flavorful oils that give desserts their wow factor, and I think about her whenever I make this treat.

Texture Options

You can enjoy this pie in different ways depending on how you chill it. For something soft and mousse-like that reminds you of soft serve, just stick with the minimum fridge time. The filling will hold its shape but still feel gentle when you eat it. If you want something more like the original frozen popsicle, leave it in the freezer for at least an hour. It'll get firmer but won't be hard like regular ice cream. You can even serve it completely frozen when it's super hot outside and you need something really cold.

Make It Your Own

The orange version is always a hit, but you can switch things up easily. Try swapping orange Jello for strawberry, lime, or raspberry for totally different flavors. You'll follow the same steps regardless. You can also play around with the crust using graham crackers for a more traditional pie feel or chocolate cookies for something that contrasts nicely with the citrus. Want a grown-up version? Add a spoonful of orange liqueur like Grand Marnier or Cointreau to the filling for some fancy flavor.

Perfect Slicing Technique

Getting clean slices can be tricky with creamy pies. For one that's been in the fridge, dunk your knife in hot water and wipe it dry between cuts for the neatest edges. If you're serving it frozen, let it sit out for about 5 minutes first so the crust doesn't break apart. A pie server with a thin edge works best for lifting pieces without messing up the layers. You might want to cut the whole pie at once, then put the slices back in the freezer so they're ready to grab later.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How long should the dessert chill?

For a creamy texture, 2 hours in the fridge should work well. If you’re aiming for a firmer, frozen style, let it set in the freezer for an hour. Cooling is key for it to keep shape!

→ Should I serve this from the fridge or freezer?

You can do either depending on your choice! Keep it cool from the fridge for a rich, softer pie. Or let it freeze for a more ice cream-like texture when you serve.

→ How long will it last once made?

As long as it’s wrapped well, you can store it in your fridge up to a week. Need it to last longer? Freeze it, and you’ll get about 3 months of storage time.

→ Can I switch the cookies in the base?

Totally! Shortbread works wonderfully, but you could try graham crackers, ginger cookies, or vanilla wafers. Just keep the amount of crumbs and butter balanced.

→ Is a food processor required for this?

Nope, you don’t need one! For the crust, toss the cookies in a baggie and crush them with a rolling pin. As for the orange puree, you could use a blender or give them a thorough mash and strain by hand—it might just be a little chunkier.

→ Could I swap fresh oranges for mandarin oranges?

Yep, canned mandarins are a nice option if fresh ones aren’t handy. Be sure to drain them well and maybe scale back the added orange juice a little since mandarins can be sweeter and juicier.