Pin it
If you've got a crowd to feed in a hurry, these crispy strawberry cheesecake sammies will absolutely save you. Dream of crunchy, golden bread with a sweet tangy cream cheese center packed with juicy berries. Every mouthful is like cheesecake married with French toast and bam, you're done in about fifteen minutes.
The first time was a Saturday morning when I threw these together on a whim. Now, the kids ask for them for birthday breakfasts... and honestly, they even show up for midnight munchies.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Cream cheese: Makes the dreamy soft center—full-fat blocks are best and don’t forget to let them come up to room temp for stress-free mixing
- Granulated sugar: Gives just the right sweetness—superfine sugar blends in the smoothest
- Vanilla extract: Pulls the flavors together so everything tastes like you meant it—a splash of good vanilla makes a difference
- Strawberries: Fresh makes these sing but thawed and patted-dry frozen ones are handy too
- Strawberry jam: Ramps up the berry punch—choose one loaded with real chunks for texture
- White bread: Fluffy and soft is the move—trim off crusts for a pro look and a perfect crunch
- Eggs: Hold everything together for that perfect outside—think French toast vibes
- Milk: Makes the egg bath silky—whole milk adds a little luxury
- Ground cinnamon: Totally up to you—adds a warm hint of spice if you have a new jar lying around
- Butter: Helps crisp up each sandwich—grab unsalted and use plenty for that gorgeous color
- Graham crumbs: For those extra crunch lovers—roll the edges for more bite, freshly crushed are awesome
- Powdered sugar: The big bakery finish—sift it if you want no lumps
- Sliced strawberries & maple syrup or honey: Finish it all off—pile on pretty fruit and a sweet drizzle
Easy How-To Steps
- Get the Cream Cheese Mix Ready
- Put cream cheese, sugar, and vanilla in a bowl. Whisk or beat till it’s super smooth—no grainy bits. Toss in your fresh strawberries and a spoon of jam, mixing just enough so everything’s evenly dotted but berries stay chunky.
- Build the Sammies
- Arrange four slices of bread with no crusts. Slather each with a fat layer of filling right to the very edge. Top with another slice—the more you press the edges, the better the filling stays put.
- Mix Up the Egg Dip
- In a dish, whisk up eggs and milk till it’s totally blended, then sprinkle in cinnamon if that’s your jam. Dunk each sandwich in, let the extra run off, and if you like, dip those edges in graham crumbs for crunch.
- Toast ‘Em Up
- Add butter to a nonstick pan on medium. Wait for it to start bubbling. Toss in a corner of bread—when it sizzles, you’re set. Cook sandwiches till the bottom is deep gold, about two or three minutes, then flip and do the same on the other side. Turn down the heat if they brown too quick.
- Finish & Serve
- Move your golden sammies to paper towels to soak up extra butter. Let ‘em rest a sec, slice each on a diagonal because it looks cool, dust with as much powdered sugar as you want, toss on extra strawberries, then pour on honey or syrup for the final touch.
Pin it
Nobody beats that center—when you bite and hit a big, warm berry it’s magic. My crew never skips a snow cloud of powdered sugar on top. Every time we make them, I swear the table gets louder and goofier.
Storing Made Simple
You’ll want to eat these crispy wonders right away, but if you end up with leftover sandwiches, let them cool totally. Wrap in foil or seal in a container. To bring the crunch back, reheat in a skillet over gentle heat. Skip the microwave though—it just makes the bread soggy.
Swap Ideas
No white bread? Go with brioche or whole wheat to change it up. If strawberries are out, try raspberries or blueberries—texture will be different but still good. Stir in a pinch of lemon zest for extra zing. If you need it vegan, dairy-free cream cheese and any plant milk work in a pinch.
Pin it
How to Serve
Try ‘em cut into quarters for party bites, pile next to whipped cream and ice cream for the full dessert effect, or add a tiny sprinkle of flaky salt after frying to really pop the flavors for grown-up brunch.
Story Behind It
You’d spot deep-fried cheesecake at fairs all over the US, but at home, it’s totally a mashup of classic strawberry cheesecake and French toast. It’s sweet, fun, and instantly loved by all ages.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use frozen strawberries?
You can, just let them thaw first and dab off any extra liquid so your filling doesn’t get runny.
- → How do I prevent the filling from leaking?
Squish the sandwich edges together tight before you dunk it in the egg. That way the creamy middle stays put while frying.
- → Can I make them ahead?
Sure, build them the night before. Pop in the fridge and fry right before eating for best crunch.
- → What bread works best?
Go for soft white bread, no crusts. It fries up crunchy and holds the filling just right.
- → Are there any topping suggestions?
Shake on some powdered sugar, pour over a little maple syrup or honey, and toss on a few strawberry slices.